Two prices can cover different work. Compare the roof areas, removal, decking allowances, underlayment, flashing, ventilation and cleanup line by line.
Put both proposals side by side and mark any item that one covers and the other omits. Ask each estimator to explain the difference in writing so you can compare the scopes and understand which costs could change.
If you're comparing replacement options, ask Dekoven Roofing for a written estimate for your property.
Two roofing proposals with similar totals can include very different scopes. Comparing them fairly means reading the line items, not just the bottom line.
Write each item as a row and each proposal as a column. Gaps show up quickly. If a line is missing, ask whether it is included, excluded or simply unmentioned.
A roofer who answers these questions clearly is giving you information you will need later.
Once scopes match, price comparisons mean something. If they do not match, ask each roofer to price the same scope.
Yes, if scopes differ. Asking each roofer to price the same scope makes comparison fair.
Check what is missing before assuming it is a better deal.
Two or three is common. More can make comparison harder without adding much.
Related: Request a replacement estimate
Practical roofing guidance for property owners and managers in Milwaukee, southeastern Wisconsin and Houston.
